By Amhar Rasyid
Jambi, Nov 22, 2026
Assalamu’alaikum dear brothers and sisters, to whom it may concern. I’ve appreciated much my colleague Mr. Sudarnoto’s lately efforts to bring peace in the Middle East, especially in Palestine. Prof. Dr. Sudarnoto Abdul Hakim is currently the President of Asia-Pacific Coalition for al-Quds and Palestine (APCQP) and nominated as one of the 50 most influential figures in support of the Palestine cause. Congratulations!
In one hand, the political efforts to bring about peace in the region have spent many years, and much money. To the best I know the Palestinian’s struggle may had begun long before since Yasser Arafat’s time during which I was a student in Egypt namely that of Ahmed al-Sukheiry. On the other hand, the struggle of the oppressed Palestinians has caused bloodshed, and international grievances. A number of peace talks have been carried out even at Camp David which finally came to nothing but even worse. Seen from such a variety of efforts I’m personally not so sure to realize an eternal peace in Palestine whatever it be just signed diplomatically on paper. I am one of the pessimists in the world. Ye, it is me.
To solve the Palestine cause, in my opinion, let me elaborate it in 2 steps whatever they may seem ridiculous for you and for the politicians as well. Firstly, eradicate the deepest psychological distress among the Palestinians. It is very important to uproot it. Why? Because once the voice of instigator echoed in public sphere or in mosques to commemorate the confiscated lands of the Palestine by the Jews, it easily leads to new riots. The Palestine generation after generation will not forget the inherited issue since the time of their predecessors and hence are easily susceptible to animosity. It is the crux of the problem. Believe me! So how to solve it?
The only answer is a Property Swap (Tukar Guling). The Palestinians do in need of a safety country. Far from political turbulences, they want to live in a prosperous land where generations after generations will survive. While most of the Indonesians are said being their brothers, their sisters in Islam. It means that both the Palestinians and the Indonesians share a common ground of friendship. Therefore, it is a ‘ticket’ to exchange the country: both the Palestinians will get an island or two or three, say, in southern part of Maluku near Papua and we the Indonesians will get in return their current territory. As a matter of fact, we need a territory close to the precinct of the Holy City to manage the Pilgrimage. Above all the exchange will also to eliminate the long-lasting animosity, the deep psychological distress between the Palestinians and the Jews.
Secondly, to carry out the Territory Swap project undoubtedly entails a new international political issue at stake. I do realize that not everybody will welcome my opinion, not every nation in the world, not every Indonesians, even not every Palestinians either. What if they were to agree? The Palestinians, first of all, should do a referendum and the Indonesians as well. I think it is a difficult task but promising. Finally let the UNHCR (United Nations) to manage the problem. By doing this I think the ‘Dream’ of the Palestianians to live peacefully will come true. It is a better solution. What do you think? Thank you for reading a ridiculous, but sincere political idea of mine. Amhar Rasyid, Jambi.